Archived Pages

▼

Monday, October 26, 2026

Haunting legal panel talks human history of witchcraft

RJ Peltz-Steele with Google Gemini CC0 1.0
Halloween offers occasion to revisit last year's instant-classic continuing legal education program, "Malleus Maleficarium: Witchcraft Persecution in the 21st Century."

Recorded just before Halloween in 2025 by the International Criminal Law Committee of the International Law Section, American Bar Association, "Malleus Maleficarium" is free to stream (and embedded below) at the time of this writing.

The topic is historical and fanciful, yet surprisingly contemporary and serious at the same time. Here is the narrative abstract:

The "witch trials" in Early European history and during the U.S. colonial period have left an indelible mark on the way society understands how and why the "witch hunts" took place. Since the witch trials which were held in Europe and in Salem [Massachusetts], many of the women who were found to be alleged witches have been exonerated. Unfortunately, this has not necessarily translated into the end of witch hunts or the persecution of innocent people in the name of sorcery or other forms of "magic." This session examines witchcraft persecution occurring in the 21st century across the world, with impunity. The panel also discusses how communities respond to these acts and what lessons can be gleaned from history to prevent persecution of innocent people.

Two of my outstanding students moderated the program, Grace Nguyen and Erasmus Ablernarh. Both are officers of the International Law Students Association, which I co-advise at UMass Law with my colleague, office neighbor, and fellow former Arkansan, Professor Frances Rudko.

Presently a 3L in my Comparative Law class and a participant in the Global Law Classroom, Nguyen worked last summer as a certified law clerk at the Orange County District Attorney's Office, Santa Ana, in her native area of Greater Los Angeles, California. Also a 3L, Ablernarh clerked last summer at Cellai Law Offices in Braintree, Massachusetts. Ablernarh holds a master's in languages and business and European management from Université d'Orléans, Centre-Val de Loire, France, and earned his bachelor's in education from the University of Cape Coast, Ghana, one of my favorite places on the African continent.

English translation in the Internet Archive
The actual "Malleus Maleficarium" is a book, written in Latin and first published in Germany in 1486. Author Heinrich Kramer was commissioned by Pope Innocent VIII to investigate witchcraft, and the Malleus Maleficarium, which translates as "hammer of witches," was his report. Kramer fixated weirdly on women's sexuality and hyperbolized the threat of witchcraft to the church and social order.

The report was not well received by the French Inquisition, which regarded it as too severe. The French Inquisition, a papal task force to combat heresy, was not known for the brutality that later characterized the Spanish Inquisition. But still, when the Inquisition thinks you're taking something too seriously, .... 

The church distanced itself from the Malleus, and from Kramer, who was increasingly regarded as unhinged. Unfortunately for generations of women, however, common people still identified the Malleus with church authority, and the book appealed to the zeitgeist. The Malleus inspired periodic movements of barbaric persecution from the 16th to 18th centuries, including the Salem witch trials of the 1690s.

Witchcraft—and the fear of it, and fascination with it—are not unique to European-American tradition and are not relegated to history. The 2026 FIFA World Cup sparked news reports about the Ghanaian witch doctor whose curse prevented UK striker Harry Kane from scoring. A true-crime docuseries on Hulu now, "Swipe Right on the Devil," is winning audiences with a tale of murder and "so-called witchcraft." 

The "Malleus Maleficarium" panel discussed both the history and present-day persecution of witches around the world, and speculated on what it is about human nature that so doggedly insists that there be witches.

These were the expert panelists:

  • Govind Kelkar, Ph.D. in the political economy of China; professor and executive director of the GenDev Centre for Research and Innovation, Gurgaon, Haryana, India; and visiting professor at the Council for Social Development and Institute for Human Development, New Delhi, India. A feminist scholar, she has authored 16 books focusing on gender relations in Asia.
  • Dev Nathan, research director at the GenDev Centre for Research and Innovation, Gurgaon, Haryana, India; and visiting professor at the Institute for Human Development, New Delhi, iIndia. An economist, he is co-author with Kelkar of Witch Hunts: Culture, Patriarchy and Structural Transformation (Cambridge Univ. Press 2020).
  • Jacqueline Mbogo, a Ph.D. candidate in African women studies; a consultant on women, peace, and security development, based in Nairobi, Kenya; and at the time of the program, chief of party and team leader for the UKAID Reducing Insecurity and Violent Extremism Programme, Kenya. She was awarded the Order of Golden Warrior (OGW) by the President of Kenya for her contribution to Kenyan peace and security.
  • Jan Machielsen, historian and reader in early modern history at Cardiff University, Wales, UK. An expert on early modern witchcraft and demonology, he is author of The Basque Witch-Hunt: A Secret History (Bloomsbury 2025), winner of the 2025 American Association of Publishers PROSE award for best book in European History.

Have a look at the video. It's enchanting.


Monday, October 5, 2026

Seeking to fund climate mitigation with 'super tort' relief, U.S. cities, states struggle with federalism

RJ Peltz-Steele with Google Gemini CC0 1.0
In today's First Monday in the U.S. Supreme Court, the Court heard and livestreamed oral arguments in a bellwether climate case.

In Suncor Energy Inc. v. County Commissioners of Boulder County, the city and county of Boulder, Colorado, demand compensation from Big Oil actors for damage wrought by fossil-fuel-driven climate change, such as floods, droughts, extreme heat, heavy precipitation, floods, and wildfires.

Before the Court are issues far preliminary to the substantive. The corporate defendants argue that the public suits are preempted by federal statutes and by constitutional limitations on state power vis-à-vis both the federal government and other states.

The Court decision in the case will have implications for a wave of similar lawsuits by local governments across the country, such as Honolulu, San Francisco, and Baltimore, and by states, such as Minnesota and Rhode Island. Writ large, the suit has implications for state- and municipal-government efforts to use litigation to fill coffers to respond to a range of crises, not limited to climate change, such as air and water pollution, epidemics of drug addiction, failures of physical infrastructure, and vulnerabilities in cybersecurity.

State and local governments invoke multiple legal theories with tort law, sometimes in this context called "super tort," leading the way. The federal government, with either party in the White House, has resisted super tort theories—excepting an impulse of the Biden Administration—viewing them as a threat to coherent national policy. Meanwhile public plaintiffs naturally want to keep their claims in state courts, which they rate as friendliest to state claims, and in which the states naturally have the most sway over interpretation of state law. 

Pumpjacks in Williams County, North Dakota, 2026.
RJ Peltz-Steele CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
A skeptic such as I might say that federal resistance is grounded in bought-and-sold federal politicians having more interest in perpetuating campaign contributions from the corporatocracy than in ensuring public health and security. At the same time, I recognize that there must be some guardrails on a state's latitude to so distort tort litigation as to effectuate tax or confiscation.

Today's argument was wide-ranging, from disparate understandings of causation in state tort law, to choice-of-law principles, federal preemption, and limitations on state power over interstate commerce and U.S. foreign affairs.

"Everybody agrees that state tort law is a form of regulation," Justice Amy Coney Barrett prefaced one question to Boulder County attorney Kevin Russell. The observation highlights the balance that courts in tort cases try to maintain in constraining their power in corrective justice, that is, righting wrongs between parties before the court, while acknowledging that tort litigation has, and is supposed to have, reverberations in politics and public policy.

Suncor Energy attorney Kannon Shanmugam summed up the defense position in context: "This case and others like it reflect an all too regrettable trend of trying to resolve major political issues in court rather than leaving them to the political branches where they belong."

As I asserted some years ago, the courts are being drawn more and more into the uncomfortable domain of political disputes as the public grows frustrated with the dysfunctions that paralyze the political branches.

Post-argument analyses will abound. I suggest checking out SCOTUSblog and Reason. The oral argument at C-SPAN is embedded below. The case, again, is Suncor Energy (U.S.A.), Inc. v. County Commissioners of Boulder County, No. 25-70 (U.S. oral argument Oct. 5, 2026).