Sunday, November 15, 2026

Norwegian footballer claims publicity right in ponytail

Image from Norwegian Air Shuttle ad
Presumed ©; demonstrative fair use
As my Manchester City Football Club teeters in the face of punitive relegation as threatened consequence of financial improprieties, I was pleased during this international break to be distracted by an amusing Erling Haaland story in intellectual property law.

As both an MCFC supporter and Norway aficionado, the latter owing to long-time family friends there, I recently devoured Haaland: The Biography by Norwegian football writer and broadcaster Lars Sivertsen. Erling Braut Haaland is a Bryne-reared, 6'5", now-26-year-old striker who took Premier League football by storm, shattering records and quickly establishing himself as one of the top players in the world. 

The best thing about Haaland for my money is that he also seems like a super decent guy, just a boy from Bryne. He's the sort of superstar who remembers the little people, such as the woman who cooked for his youth team and always made sure he ate.

Both athletes, Haaland's parents inspired a relentless work ethic and sporting values such as loyalty and teamsmanship. His mother, Gry Marita Braut, was a champion heptathlete for Norway in the 1990s, and his father is Alf-Inge "Alfie" Haaland, a footballer who played his best years at City, before injury ended his career. 

For five years of footballing, Haaland sported a blonde ponytail. As Inc. put it, the immediately recognizable styling became a "business asset." In 2024, Haaland bought a stake in a hair-tie company and became a brand ambassador for a shampoo, Inc.explained. It was headline news when Haaland turned up for the 2026-27 season sporting a new buzz cut. Balding former manager Pep Guardiola (and I) was aghast at the wasted potential. 

Erling Haaland, 2022
Egghead06 via Wikimedia Commons
CC BY-SA 4.0

Meanwhile, Haaland had sported the usual ponytail when he played for the Norwegian national team at the World Cup over the summer. Norwegian Air Shuttle, a low-cost airline based outside of Oslo, ran a World Cup advertising campaign at that time featuring a plane with a blonde ponytail and the slogan, "We've never looked more Norwegian."

Alas, the campaign apparently did not have Haaland's imprimatur. Haaland sued in Oslo District Court, according to AFP via Courthouse News on October 1.

Tom Collins and Kathy Harford at Stevens & Bolton (UK) penned an insightful legal analysis from a multi-jurisdictional perspective of the overlapping intellectual property theories implicated by the reported claim, including right of publicity (not available in UK) and trademark.

From a U.S. perspective, Haaland's claim is strong, even in the absence of a registered trademark, provided there is right-of-publicity protection in the jurisdiction. Faber Law tracks right of publicity in the United States, where just more than half of states have statutes, and maybe a dozen more recognize a common law right.

The Restatement (Third) of Unfair Competition (1995) describes tortious appropriation as when "[o]ne ... appropriates the commercial value of a person’s identity by using without consent the person’s name, likeness, or other indicia of identity for purposes of trade ...."

The Haaland claim seems a slam dunk, insofar as this rule pertains. There is zero question that the Norwegian Air Shuttle ad was aimed at conjuring the likeness of Haaland in the mind of the viewer. Norwegian might claim its purpose to have been World Cup patriotism, in part. But there can be no serious doubt that the company wishes to sell tickets, too, and the ad was designed to further trade. Though Norwegian abandoned trans-Atlantic service amid the pandemic, it operates flights to cities across Europe, including London and Manchester. As a consumer, I'm left with the impression that support for Haaland and support for Norwegian are interchangeable.

I have found no English-language source that has laid eyes on the Haaland complaint, but MiGFlug reported that the case arises under the Norwegian Marketing Control Act, which makes sense. That's the statutory mechanism that creates right-of-publicity liability in civil-law Norway. As explained by Oslo-based Bryn Aarflot, the Marketing Control Act covers "lookalike" claims even in the absence of trademark registration. 

From the Kongesagaer (1899 ed.)
Internet Archive, public domain
The Haaland claim arises when celebrities and high-profile athletes increasingly, and with mixed results, are seeking intellectual property protection for abstractions that conjure identity in the mind of the viewer, without express reference, such as sport celebration moves. Collins and Harford observed that artificial intelligence will make claims over such abstract images more frequent, as AI makes it easier to put a ponytail on an airplane.  

According to the Sweden Herald, Haaland v. Norwegian Air Shuttle is scheduled for trial in Oslo District court on March 16-18, 2027.

Meanwhile, Haaland is making news still for being the boy who made good for hometown Bryne. Erling and father Alfie recently spent 1.3 million Norwegian kroner, about US$136,000, to purchase at auction a rare book of Viking history and donate it to the Bryne local library. According to The Guardian, the book is "the only surviving privately owned edition" of Snorre Sturlasons Kongesagaer (Snorre Sturlason’s Royal Sagas), published in 1594. The Guardian explained:

Snorri’s royal sagas chronicle the history of the Old Norse Viking and medieval kings of Norway, regarded by many Norwegians as a key document of national identity. The stories, about kings, queens, farmers and warriors, were first told orally and then written down by the Icelander Snorri Sturlason in the mid-13th century.

Via video, Haaland told assembled Bryne children that he was interested in Vikings from a young age and reads to his son, who turns two in December.

No comments:

Post a Comment