Showing posts with label Robert Hecht. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Robert Hecht. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 26, 2023

Per 'modern ethical standards,' Mass. museum surrenders $5m bronze for repatriation to Turkey

Portrait of  Lady (AD 160-180)
Public domain/Daderot via Wikimedia Commons
A story of art crime touched Massachusetts early in September, as the Worcester Art Museum let go of a bronze bust of estimated $5m worth for repatriation to Turkey.

The museum purchased Portrait of a Lady (A Daughter of Marcus Aurelius?) in 1966 from Robert E. Hecht, an antiquities dealer. If that name is familiar to American easterners, yes, Hecht was a descendant of the Hechts, 19th century Jewish immigrants from Germany who started a department store chain in Baltimore, Md., my hometown, in 1857. What became "Hecht's" had 80 or more stores in the mid-Atlantic region. When I was a kid, my maternal grandmother loved to peruse the goods at what she still called "Hecht Brothers." The company was swallowed by Macy's in 2006.

Robert Hecht had a checkered career as an antiquities dealer based in Paris. He died in 2012 at age 92. In his obituary, the N.Y. Times described Hecht as "an American expatriate antiquities dealer who skipped in and out of trouble for much of his career, weathering accusations that he trafficked in illicit artifacts." Hecht denied ever having handled stolen goods knowingly. Late in life, he was charged with trafficking in Italy, but the Italian court ruled that the statute of limitations had run.

Hecht Co., Hyattsville, Md., 1959
Library of Congress
Revelation of Portrait's illicit provenance came to the Worcester Art Museum from the office of Manhattan District Attorney Alvin L. Bragg, Jr. And if that name sounds familiar, yes, he's the one on TV charging former President Donald Trump with falsifying business records—for my money, charges of a nature that should have been pursued decades ago and always should have been the people's focus, more than recent, politically charged allegations related to the election in Georgia or insurrection in D.C.

When not on TV for a press conference about Trump charges, Bragg has become famous in the art world for his aggressive campaign to repatriate stolen works. Portrait is but one entry in an extraordinary catalog. A recent press release, for example, announced the return of Nazi-looted art to families of Holocaust victims. The work of the Antiquities Trafficking Unit is impressive, though the D.A.'s press releases read like a vanity project. Must every headline begin with "D.A. Bragg"?

I was keen to see what kind of legal documents the D.A. would file in Massachusetts to take possession of stolen antiquities. But there are no filings that I have found. The Worcester Art Museum "cooperated with the investigation" according to its press release and surrendered Portrait voluntarily.

Renaissance Court, Worcester Art Museum, 2021
The museum not only cooperated, but the press release doth protest too much, methinks, to locate the museum on the moral high ground. Upon purchase of Portrait in 1966, the museum "was provided with limited information about the object's history," the press release said. The D.A. "provided new information" in 2023. "The Museum had never previously received a claim or learned of any defect in ownership."

Colgate art history professor Elizabeth Marlowe doesn't buy it. A student of Bubon, the ancient Roman capital of Lycia, where the Bronze was found in Turkey, Marlowe told WGBH that the museum in 1966 "would have known ... that Hecht was 'a totally shady character'" who had been banned from Turkey, and that the Roman object came from Turkey. Professor of art crime at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice Erin Thompson told WGBH that the acquisition was "like Pablo Escobar giving you a big pile of white powder and claiming you had no suspicion it could be drugs."

Benin Bronze of a Portuguese soldier
at the National Museum of Nigeria, Lagos, 2022.

RJ Peltz-Steele CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
Notwithstanding its protestations, the museum acknowledged that "greater diligence" is brought to bear on acquisition today. Director Matthias Waschek said in the press release, "The ethical standards applicable to museums are much changed since the 1960s, and the Museum is committed to managing its collection consistent[ly] with modern ethical standards."

That statement rings true, and I don't blame the museum. To the contrary, current ethical standards are still in flux, and museums are caught in the middle. John Oliver lambasted museums in 2022. While I loved the Oliver segment and agree with his pro-repatriation stance in principle, I find the reality more complicated.

Oliver correctly recognized that statements from western institutions fretting about the security of antiquities if returned to their home countries feel cringeworthily patronizing and colonialist. Oliver highlighted the case of the Benin Bronzes. Nigeria has demanded that the British Museum return more than 900 bronze sculptures the British Empire looted from the Nigerian Kingdom of Benin in today's Edo State (not to be confused with the country of Benin). When I visited Nigeria in 2022, I saw replicas of missing pieces. I met Nigerian people who clearly felt a present and keen sense of injury in the absence of cherished artifacts that define tribal history, culture, and identity. Nigerians should be able to see and experience their own history in museums, just like people in Britain and America. Yet the vast majority of Nigerians will never have the resources to visit the British Museum.

Me and an oversized jollof rice pot at the National Museum, Lagos, 2022.
Learn more at the Kitchen Butterfly.

RJ Peltz-Steele CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
At the same time, I watched in horror at the destruction of the Buddhas of Bamiyan in 2001 and the sacking of the Cairo museum in 2013, the latter of which I visited in the 20-aughts. The Antiques Coalition documents devastating losses in the 2010s at museums in Egypt, Iraq, Syria, Mali, and Yemen. Say what you will about western imperialism, and there's plenty to say, museum sackings are much less common in London and D.C. When asked by a mate of mine how Nigeria would safeguard the bronzes—the country is in civil war in the north—a museum guide said that the items should be returned along with financial support to build secure facilities. OK. But already, then, the matter becomes more complicated, revealing that there's a legitimate debate to be had about how and where we care for the world's cultural heritage.

Founded in 1896, the Worcester Art Museum has plenty to see. The property houses a 12th-century French Benedictine priory, rebuilt stone by stone in 1933. The museum's 38,000-item collection includes more than 2,000 armor pieces, acquired only in 2013 and featured in rotating displays. A special exhibition from October to March, "Freedom to Say What I Please," will feature the multimedia art of activist, artist, and author Faith Ringgold.