Monday, November 16, 2026

Ala. defamation verdict evidences changing times

RJ Peltz-Steele with Google Gemini CC0 1.0
In late August, an Alabama jury entered a $9.25 million defamation verdict against The New York Times, signaling that impunity long enjoyed by the institutional press can no longer be taken for granted.

The case arose from a Times story that erroneously placed plaintiff Kai Spears, a University of Alabama freshman basketball player, at the scene of a fatal shooting on campus.

Commentary on the case is abundant, and I don't aim to restate it better. I recommend coverage by George MJ Perry at "Abuse of Process," Eugene Volokh at Reason, Bill Grueskin at the Columbia Journalism Review, and Katie Robertson at the Times itself. 

Multiple media outlets reported that the defamation loss was the Times's first in 50 years. The verdict included $7.5 million in punitive damages, which the court reduced to comport with a punitive-to-compensatory statutory ratio cap of three to one. At the time of this writing and since September 28, defense motions are pending to toss the jury verdict (JNOV) and for reduction of damages (remittitur).

What's remarkable about the case is not the verdict, but that Spears reached the jury at all. As I wrote most recently here in October 2025 and in 2 Tortz (2025 ed.) ("Reconsidering Sullivan"), and verbalized in Dan Greenberg's American Libel (2025), the "actual malice" doctrine that originated with New York Times Co. v. Sullivan (U.S. 1964) perversely, if well meaningly, incentivizes sloppy journalism and presents genuinely injured plaintiffs with insurmountable obstacles to tort compensation.

Key rulings in the instant case surprisingly went against the Times and likewise against extant if modestly waning media defense bulwarks some 60 years old. First, the plaintiff was ruled a private, not public, figure. Only public figures trigger the federal constitutional doctrine of Sullivan. 

A first big problem with Sullivan has been that the public-private distinction has eroded in the information age, in which anyone can be a "celebrity" of a sort, in some niche market. Spears might not have been a public figure as a freshman walk-on circa 1970, but every member on the Alabama squad has a public persona online today. The ruling thus pushes back in an effort to redraw a public-private balance fit for the internet era.

Second, even though Sullivan did not, therefore, require proof of "actual malice"—defendant's intentional falsity, actual knowledge of falsity, or reckless disregard of falsity—the plaintiff still convinced the jury of actual malice for the purpose of winning punitive damages.

A second big problem with Sullivan has been the refusal of courts to find actual malice with less than smoking-gun evidence of known falsehood, moving the actual malice rule problematically close to the old and justifiably abandoned common law concept of evil motive. The jury here heard evidence of Times arrogance and sloppiness in getting the facts rights when a young man's integrity and well-being were in jeopardy. Allowing such examination of the editorial process pushes back against a long-standing judicial norm of heedless deference to purported journalistic method.

There is a gratifying irony in that the Spears case arose in Alabama, the same state that generated Sullivan. Appeal seems inevitable. But times have changed, and I like the plaintiff's odds in today's Eleventh Circuit and U.S. Supreme Court. 

I remain committed to journalism as an enterprise and to its importance in the democratic project. But the imbalance in tort law wrought by Sullivan and progeny in fact contributed to the decay of modern journalism. Unaccountability facilitated the dissolution of professionalism, and unrequited reputational harm fostered resentment and distrust.

A turning of the tide to let tort law do its work would be in the interests of the public and journalism alike.

The case is Spears v. N.Y. Times Co., No. 7:23-cv-00692 (N.D. Ala. Aug. 31, 2026), before Judge Annemarie Carney Axon in Birmingham.

No comments:

Post a Comment