Showing posts with label Stephen Dubner. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stephen Dubner. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Should lots, not elections, choose political leaders?

RJ Peltz-Steele with Google Gemini CC0 1.0
In a recent episode of Freakonomics Radio, "Does Democracy Really Need Elections?," journalist Stephen J. Dubner explored sortition, the selection of public officials by lot.

Dubner came to the inquiry by way of his service on a criminal jury in a drug case. He was inspired by the seriousness with which jurors undertook their responsibility and rendered a verdict for the prosecution. Dubner had the defense lawyer from the case on the show to understand how lawyers understand the jury process.

But the notion of a jury chosen more or less randomly led Dubner down a rabbit hole, into the world of sortition, also called "civic lottery," which dates to Ancient Greece. Dubner explored sortition with the help of experts, including "recovering politician" Terry Bouricius, author of the Routledge open access book, Democracy Without Politicians: Government by the People (2026), and political science Professor Hélène Landemore, author of Politics Without Politicians: The Case for Citizen Rule (Penguin Random House 2026).

I thought of sortition as an interesting but fringe idea. I was wrong. Landemore explained how sortition was a dominant mode of democracy from Ancient Greece until the Enlightenment in the 18th century. According to Bouricius, "Aristotle said, lotteries are democratic, and elections are oligarchic." While some powers of government in Ancient Greece were reserved for an elite, much of governance was charged to a randomly selected citizen council.

A problem with elections, if it's not obvious, is that they favor candidates with certain personality traits, such as confidence, which might not be justified, and even a willingness to lie. The recognition accords with the idea, as old as Plato, that persons who desire power ought not be given it. Properly informed, shy and modest people are no less capable of making wise policy decisions, but they tend to get no say in modern democracy.

Of course, elections also distort democracy with money, which affords a candidate access to the electorate. The role of money might actually explain why sortition went out of favor at the very time that the United States was constituted.

According to the experts, the U.S. framers specifically wanted not to empower the masses. And it wasn't just the threat to norms of power that enslaved persons and women might mount. The framers regarded wealth and social status as indicative of the wisdom required to govern—Aristotle's oligarchy.

In other words, according to sortition advocates, the anti-democratic distortion of American politics by wealth is not a dysfunction, but a design feature. Sortition is a fix.

Dubner's exploration examined experiments with sortition as it's popped up here and there in the world, in places such as British Columbia, Iceland, Ireland, and, curiously, as reported recently by Planet Money, Connecticut. 

A problem with sortition, Dubner worked out, is getting politicians who benefit from the status quo to buy in. That might be possible, Bouricius posited, if you start on an issue-by-issue basis. There are questions that are too hot-potato for politicians, who might be eager to hand them off. Climate change might be one, he said.